| Obsidian Plate Chest Armor | | |
| Obsidian Sheet | | |
| Obsidian Spear Head | | |
| Obsidian Stag Carcass | | Used in 1 recipe. |
| Obsidian Sword | | |
| Obsidian Venison Loaf |
food | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Obsidian Venison Meat | | Used in 2 recipes.Made from 1 recipe. |
| Obsidian War Hammer | | |
| Obsidian War Hammer Head | | |
| Obsidian Wolf Carcass | | Used in 1 recipe. |
| Obsidian Wolf Chops |
food | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Obsidian Wolf Meat | | Used in 2 recipes.Made from 1 recipe. |
| Obsidian Wolf Skin Rug | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| [obsolete] Hardened Leather Strap | | |
| Oil Lamp Burner | | |
| One-Handed Blade Equipment | | Used in 1 recipe.Made from 1 recipe. |
| One-Handed Blade Patterns | | Used in 1 recipe. |
| One-Handed Bludgeon Equipment | | Used in 1 recipe.Made from 1 recipe. |
| One-Handed Bludgeon Patterns | | Used in 1 recipe. |
| One-Handed Polearm Equipment | | Used in 1 recipe.Made from 1 recipe. |
| One-Handed Polearm Patterns | | Used in 1 recipe. |
| One-Man Band Basic Hat | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| One-Man Band Basic Shirt | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| One-Man Band Fancy Hat | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| One-Man Band Fancy Shirt | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Onion | 4 gold | Used in 38 recipes. |
| Onion Plant Seed |
seed16 gold | |
| Onyx Fragment (Unrefined Gemstone) | | |
| Onyx (Unrefined Gemstone) | | Used in 5 recipes. |
| Oozy Omelet |
food | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Opalis Memory Fragment | | |
| Orange Dragon Head | | |
| Orange Dye | | Used in 4 recipes.Made from 1 recipe. |
| Orange Rose | | Used in 4 recipes. |
| Orange Rose Bouquet | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Orange Rose Bush Seed |
seed10 gold | |
| Orange Rose Flower Arrangement | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Orange Wyvern Egg | | |
| Orange Wyvern Head | | Used in 1 recipe. |
| Ornate Aeronaut Boots | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Ornate Aeronaut Cap and Goggles | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Ornate Aeronaut Gloves | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Ornate Aeronaut Jacket | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Ornate Aeronaut Leggings | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Oval Rug (Dark Red) | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Oyster Meat | 8 gold | Used in 2 recipes. |
| Oyster Potpie |
food | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pacu Fillet | | Used in 1 recipe. |
| Padded Chair | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Painting (Ladies In Waiting) | | |
| Painting (Lakeside Sunrise) | | |
| Paladis White Wine | | |
| Paladis White Wine Ingredients | | Used in 1 recipe.Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pale Leech (Bait) | | |
| Palomino Horse Mount | | |
| Pan | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Papa Holly's Savory Sandwich |
food | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Paper Party Hat | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pattern: Basket Guard Rapier | | |
| Pattern: Bonesteel Crown | | |
| Pattern: Broad Hand Axe | | |
| Pattern: Cutlass of the Swashbuckler | | |
| Pattern: Dirty Cloth Boots | | |
| Pattern: Dirty Cloth Chest Armor | | |
| Pattern: Dirty Cloth Gloves | | |
| Pattern: Dirty Cloth Helm | | |
| Pattern: Dirty Cloth Leggings | | |
| Pattern: Elven Woodwind Short Bow | | |
| Pattern: Halberd of the Sun | | |
| Pattern: Ice Hammer of Jotungrund | | |
| Pattern: Kobold Hammer | | |
| Pattern: Kobold Slag Sword | | |
| Pattern: Lesser Staff | | |
| Pattern: Lesser Wand | | |
| Pattern: Long Club | | |
| Pattern: Morning Star | | |
| Pattern: Norgard Fur Hood | | |
| Pattern: Ragged Leather Boots | | |
| Pattern: Ragged Leather Chest Armor | | |
| Pattern: Ragged Leather Gloves | | |
| Pattern: Ragged Leather Helm | | |
| Pattern: Ragged Leather Leggings | | |
| Pattern Remover | | Used in 4 recipes. |
| Pattern: Rusty Axe | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Chainmail Boots | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Chainmail Chest Armor | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Chainmail Gauntlets | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Chainmail Helm | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Chainmail Leggings | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Dagger | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Halberd | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Hammer | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Plate Boots | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Plate Chest Armor | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Plate Gauntlets | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Shortsword | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Spear | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Sword | | |
| Pattern: Rusty Two-handed Sword | | |
| Pattern: Satyr Axe | | |
| Pattern: Shard of Night | | |
| Pattern: Shoddy Long Bow | | |
| Pattern: Shoddy Short Bow | | |
| Pattern: Spiked Club | | |
| Pattern: Walking Stick | | |
| Pattern: Worn Cloak | | |
| Pax Ring, Common | | Used in 1 recipe. |
| Pax Ring, Uncommon | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Peacock Bass | 3 gold | |
| Pecan Nuts | 4 gold | Used in 3 recipes. |
| Pepper | 4 gold | Used in 16 recipes. |
| Pepper Plant Seed |
seed8 gold | |
| Perennial Red Wine | | |
| Perennial Red Wine Ingredients | | Used in 1 recipe.Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pet Food, Bear Bites |
pet-food | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pet Food, Dragon Kibbles |
pet-food | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pet Food, Fishy Nibblers |
pet-food | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pet Food, Rabbit Pate' |
pet-food | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pet Food, Venison Jerky |
pet-food | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pew | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pewter Bowl | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pewter Cup | | |
| Pewter Fork | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pewter Jug | | |
| Pewter Mug | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pewter Pitcher | | |
| Pewter Plate | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pewter Spoon | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pewter Table Knife | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Phoenix Head | | Used in 1 recipe. |
| Phoenix Talon | | Used in 2 recipes. |
| Phonograph | | Made from 2 recipes. |
| Piano | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pickaxe |
tool80 gold | |
| Pickaxe of Prosperity |
tool | |
| Pickled Plant Pollen |
food | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Piece of Canvas Fabric | | Used in 16 recipes.Made from 1 recipe. |
| Piece of Pumpkin Pie | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pie Dough | 2 gold | Used in 13 recipes.Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pig Carcass | | Used in 1 recipe. |
| Pike | | Used in 1 recipe. |
| Pike Fillet | | Used in 1 recipe.Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pillow | | Used in 1 recipe.Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pine Binding | | Made from 2 recipes. |
| Pine Board | | Used in 3 recipes.Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pine Crossbow Stock | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pine Handle | | Used in 2 recipes.Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pine Heartwood | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pine Long Bowstave | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pine or Maple Binding | | Used in 4 recipes. |
| Pine or Maple Board | | Used in 10 recipes. |
| Pine or Maple Pole | | Used in 3 recipes. |
| Pine or Maple Timber | | Used in 8 recipes. |
| Pine or Maple Wood | | Used in 11 recipes. |
| Pine Pole | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pine Resin | | Used in 5 recipes. |
| Pine Short Bowstave | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pine Strip | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pine Tar | | Used in 2 recipes. |
| Pine Timber | | Used in 17 recipes.Made from 2 recipes. |
| Pine Tree Bark | | Used in 9 recipes. |
| Pine Wood | | Used in 19 recipes. |
| Pine Wood Staff | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pink Dye | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pink Rose | | Used in 5 recipes. |
| Pink Rose Bouquet | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pink Rose Bush Seed |
seed10 gold | |
| Pink Rose Flower Arrangement | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Pirate Feathered Tricorn Hat |
armor | |
| Pirate Hook Hand Gloves |
armor | |
| Pirate Jacket with Strap |
armor | |
| Pirate Pants with Boot and Pegleg |
armor | |
| Pitchfork | | |
| Plain Bench | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Stovepipe | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Alchemy Ground Sign | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Alchemy Hanging Sign | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Alchemy Wall Sign | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Armor Ground Sign | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Armor Hanging Sign | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Armor Wall Sign | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Armor & Weapon Ground Sign | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Armor & Weapon Hanging Sign | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Armor & Weapon Wall Sign | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Blacksmith Ground Sign | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Blacksmith Hanging Sign | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Blacksmith Wall Sign | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Hospitaller Ground Sign | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plain Wood Hospitaller Hanging Sign | | |
| Plain Wood Hospitaller Wall Sign | | |
| Plank of Salmon | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plant | 20 gold | Used in 24 recipes. |
| Plant (any) | | Used in 1 recipe. |
| Plant (Dracaena) | 20 gold | Used in 3 recipes. |
| Planting Barrel | 50 gold | |
| Planting Pot | 50 gold | |
| Plant (Laurentii) | 20 gold | Used in 1 recipe. |
| Plant (Pink Brush) | 20 gold | Used in 2 recipes. |
| Plate Boots | | Made from 1 recipe. |
| Plate Chest Armor | | Made from 1 recipe. |